Ensuring the Online Safety of Young People: A Call for Responsible Action

The rise of generative artificial intelligence (AI) technologies poses a significant challenge for Ireland in safeguarding its young population online. The Oireachtas children’s committee is set to address this pressing issue, acknowledging the limitations of relying solely on voluntary action by tech corporations. Dr Johnny Ryan, director of the Irish Council for Civil Liberties’ Enforce unit, emphasizes the need for proactive measures to protect young people from the potential harms of AI.

While acknowledging the potential of AI, Dr Ryan states that tech corporations have a poor record when it comes to self-improvement and responsible behavior, even in situations where lives are at stake. Putting the responsibility solely on these companies is not a feasible approach. Instead, Dr Ryan urges society to confront this issue head-on by adopting effective tools and strategies.

To that end, the Irish Council for Civil Liberties, along with more than 60 other organizations, has recently appealed to Coimisiún na Meán, Ireland’s new online regulator. They are advocating for an “inescapably binding” rule that would disable recommender systems based on user profiles by default on video platforms. Dr Ryan emphasizes that such a rule enjoys overwhelming support from the Irish public.

However, he also warns that implementing such a rule will undoubtedly meet opposition from Big Tech corporations. Despite potential resistance, Dr Ryan urges the committee to put pressure on Coimisiún na Meán to enforce strict regulations that prioritize user safety.

Artificial intelligence is already pervasive in platforms like TikTok, YouTube, Snapchat, and Instagram, shaping the content young people consume daily. Highlighting research conducted by various organizations, Dr Ryan raises concerns about the negative impact of recommender systems. The Institute for Strategic Dialogue discovered that YouTube’s algorithm frequently promotes misogynistic and hateful content to male users, while Amnesty International found that TikTok’s AI algorithm can glamorize suicide for children viewing mental health content.

Dr Ryan argues that these recommender systems manipulate and addict young people, promoting hurt, hate, self-loathing, and even suicide. As the director of the ICCL’s Enforce unit, his plea to the committee centers on the urgency of addressing this crisis effectively.

Additionally, CyberSafe Kids, a charity dedicated to online safety, draws attention to the irresponsible introduction of AI features without considering the potential consequences. The chief executive, Alex Mooney, highlights Snapchat’s ‘My AI’ feature, which quickly began providing inappropriate information to children despite being initially marketed as a helpful virtual friend.

In conclusion, safeguarding young people online requires collective responsibility and proactive measures by both regulators and tech corporations. Ireland has the opportunity to lead the world in addressing this crisis and ensuring the online safety and well-being of its youth.

Title: The Rise of Generative AI and the Need for Safeguarding Ireland’s Young Population Online

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

1. What is the main challenge faced by Ireland in relation to AI technologies?
The main challenge is safeguarding the young population online from the potential harms of generative artificial intelligence (AI) technologies.

2. Is voluntary action by tech corporations sufficient to address this issue?
No, the Oireachtas children’s committee acknowledges the limitations of relying solely on voluntary action from tech corporations and emphasizes the need for proactive measures.

3. Who is Dr Johnny Ryan and what does he advocate for?
Dr Johnny Ryan is the director of the Irish Council for Civil Liberties’ Enforce unit. He advocates for proactive measures and effective tools to protect young people from the potential harms of AI.

4. What rule is being advocated for by the Irish Council for Civil Liberties and other organizations?
They are advocating for an “inescapably binding” rule that would disable recommender systems based on user profiles by default on video platforms.

5. What concerns are raised about recommender systems in platforms like YouTube and TikTok?
Recommender systems have been found to promote misogynistic and hateful content on YouTube and glamorize suicide on TikTok, potentially causing harm to young people.

6. How does Dr Ryan argue that recommender systems affect young people?
Dr Ryan argues that these systems manipulate and addict young people, promoting hurt, hate, self-loathing, and even suicide.

7. What is the role of CyberSafe Kids in this issue?
CyberSafe Kids draws attention to the irresponsible introduction of AI features without considering the potential consequences, highlighting the case of Snapchat’s ‘My AI’ feature.

8. What is the plea made by Dr Ryan to the committee?
Dr Ryan pleads for urgent action to address this crisis effectively, emphasizing the need for strict regulations that prioritize user safety.

Definitions:

– Generative artificial intelligence (AI): AI technologies that can produce original and creative outputs, such as generating content or making recommendations based on user profiles.

– Recommender systems: AI algorithms that suggest content or products based on user preferences, behavior, or past interactions.

– Coimisiún na Meán: Ireland’s new online regulator responsible for overseeing online safety and implementing regulations.

– Misogynistic content: Content that promotes hatred, discrimination, or violence against women or girls.

– Mental health content: Content related to mental health issues, including suicide, self-harm, and well-being.

Suggested Related Links:

1. Irish Council for Civil Liberties
2. CyberSafe Kids
3. Coimisiún na Meán

Privacy policy
Contact